Scott said: Detailed description of the problem Using the Charactermancer to advance the BARD(lore bard) class from 9 to 10, the Charactermancer allows two spells to be selected as magical secrets, and then two more spells to be added for number of spells increase. This should actually be only two additional spells allowed, not 4 according to the PHB. Yep, and I believe the main reason people make this mistake is because the first sub was Lore Bard who has a special version of Magical Secrets earlier that does NOT do this so whatever dev goes to fix this better not screw up Lore Bards Level 6 Magical secrets which is the only one that is not counted against the bard spells known.