Hey Markus, For Fallout, Tag Skills actually compare to your Skill Rank, instead of the target number, when determining additional critical successes! In your examples, every value below the target number of 8 is indeed a success, and the natural 1 is a critical success - but only rolls equal to or below your Energy Weapons Skill Rank of 3 are scored as bonus critical successes. In your third screenshot, for instance, the 1 and 2 are both critical successes (+ 2 each), but the 6 and 8 are regular successes (+ 1 each) as they're below or equal to your target number, but above your skill rank. This leads to the total of 6 successes.