I want my players to be able to click a single macro that will ask them two questions. The first question is what monster type you are harvesting, and the second is which stat are you using to make the check. I have created 12 macros for this that are all as shown below: Ex1 &{template:default} {{name=Carving}} {{Dragon = [[d20+ @{selected|survival_prof} + ?{which stat|STR, @{selected|strength_mod}|DEX,@{selected|dexterity_mod}} ]] | [[d20+ @{selected|survival_prof} + ?{which stat|STR, @{selected|strength_mod}|DEX,@{selected|dexterity_mod}} ]] }} Ex2 &{template:default} {{name=Carving}} {{Undead = [[d20+ @{selected|medicine_prof} + ?{which stat|STR, @{selected|strength_mod}|DEX,@{selected|dexterity_mod}} ]] | [[d20+ @{selected|medicine_prof} + ?{which stat|STR, @{selected|strength_mod}|DEX,@{selected|dexterity_mod}} ]] }} These macros work how I intend them to, asking me which stat I want applied to the roll. The problem I have is with my 'larger' macro that is being used to determine which of the above macros is activate. Current macro shown below. ?{Select Creature Type|Undead, #undead_carve|Dragon, #dragon_carve} When using this macro it prompts me to select Undead or Dragon as intended but the outcome of the selection is #undead_carve or #dragon_carve rather than activating the original macros and prompting the stat question. Any advice on what I'm doing wrong?