I am getting my players's tokens ready for our first game. I was able to successfully give control to two players and their token. However, I am unable to do this for the other two players simply because their names do not show up under the Controlled By listing.
Anything I can do from my end to add them?
Edit: I figured it would be helpful if I added what my control by list shows.
All Players
Player 1
Player 2
Me
It is missing:
Player 3
Player 4
