
I'm going to be honest, I love games based on other media. On Myth-Weavers (a Play By Post RPG website), I started about 4 different games, each of which fell apart for different reasons (lack of response time, interest died down, spent too much time looking up rules, ect.), so I figured I would have better luck if I tried doing something more real-time. So then it hit me, why not use this site?
Before I figure out the plot, I need to figure out what kind of game everyone wants to play, if anyone wants to play at all. Here's a few options I had in mind; tell me which ones you think work.
====Setting====
Setting Salad Bowl: A setting where characters where all sorts of characters co-exsist in the same world, and always have. The only thing initially set in stone is that the game takes place in the modern day; any backstorys the PCs write will automatically be incorporated into the game's canon. Contradictions between backstories (such as the nature of magic and the organizations who control it's use) will be resolved prior to the game, and can even serve as plot hooks.
Multiverse: Different characters come from different worlds/universes, and the PCs will probably need to travel to different worlds on their quest. For me, Kingdom Hearts is the default whenever I need a multiverse cosmology, though if you have another suggestion I would love to hear it.
Cataclysm: The multiverse was shattered by a dimensional cataclysm of some sort. Though some semblence of order has been restored, the source of the disaster has yet to be identified.
Some Combination of the Above: A multiverse setting with a "main" world that the game takes place in, a dimensional cataclysm in progress, a post-apocalyptic, or even post-post-apocalyptic salad bowl setting are all valid options.
====Player Characters====
The Brave and the Bold: Everyone picks an established character from a setting of their choice. Backstory alterations can be made to fit the setting better, or to put a new spin on a well-known character. Very fun to play, tends to give lots of backstory to build on, but may stifle character development.
Original Generation: Everyone plays as OCs (Original Characters), though in a multiverse setting they can come from other established worlds (for instance, an Alchemist from Fullmetal Alchemist, or a Mutant from the Marvel universe).
All Star Team Up: A mix of the two; players can choose to play as OCs or established characters. My default option.
====Campaign Goals====
Crisis: A disaster has happened, or is about to happen, and the PCs are part of a team that has come together (either by chance or choice) to deal with it.
Justice League: As above, but rather than one single threat the team deals with multiple smaller, episodic threats over the course of the Campaign instead of one big threat. My default option.
To Boldly Go!: The PCs are exploring an unknown frontier of some sort. Works best in a multiverse setting.
Villain Game: The PCs are villains (or at least anti-heroes) who have come together for a common purpose, such as to pull off a heist or take over the world. Everyone needs to agree on the tone of the game in order for this to work, however. Compare Lupin III, for instance, to some of the darker versions of The Joker. Both are criminals and revel in their status, but while Lupin III is a pretty nice guy, The Joker tends to leave a trail of corpses in his wake.
====Personal Taste====
It would also help if you let me know what your favorite Anime/Video Games/Books/Tv Shows are, so I can avoid throwing in things none of you have ever heard of.