Hello there, here is my advice on these topics 1.) Best Class/Archetype/Prestige Class that you think fits the character's theme. 2.) How well those classes play and their overall abilities/usefullness outside of combat. 3.) Which of the two character concepts would you recommend? Considering the setting/world. A. Swordsman 1. Mastery of different types of swords seems to be his main goal as a character, he is combat based (I assume). One question is what kind of variety are you looking for? When many people think of swords-masters they think of a character who only relies on his swords, and prefer's finesse over strength. Someone who likes to use a single sword in one hand. (It's what I went with) In this case consider a DEX based Duelist. You could take a look at the learned duelist, learned duelist and sword-lord classes since they fit the theme. The problems with this style seems to be first that it lacks in both damage in AC when compared to 2 handed fighting and sword and board respectively. Also if you would like to focus more one one specific type of sword you can go for a Path of War class. Do you want your character to be able to wield 2 handed weapons, two weapon fighting as well as a single sword style? Cause that would be difficult to build. I would have to look some stuff up, but putting some levels in Brawler because of martial flexibility, while taking a level in fighter or something else for proficiency. 2. Most martial classes are made for the "in combat" part. However in this campaign we are allowed a free profession and craft! So really your out of combat ability is based off what you want your profession to be. For example, you could be a armor-smith, or a carpenter, or a doctor etc. Alternatively if you mean out of combat as "preparing for combat" you can take points in survival or perception which will help exploration and stuff. B. Archer 1. Building a character that is calm and uses archery is much easier. Check out the hybrid class slayer, it might be what you are looking for. It even has a archetype called bounty hunter. There is also a third party class called bounty hunter though I've only heard of it. 2. Same as above. However if you go for slayer or something of the sort you will be useful in tracking and such. If you are going for a rogueish feel you may also be able to sneak around and scout. 3. So which one to pick? Considering the world which is better? Honestly whichever one you would like to play. We have a huge party since this is a living world, so really just play whichever you prefer. I hope something here helped. Hop on the tabletop and RP with people, maybe that will help you decide.