[5e OGL] Rolls are just plain wrong

I'm using the Roll20 5e OGL sheet for my game, and one of my character's rolls are just entirely wrong.  She has a +7 to her history, which the sheet is showing correctly, but when she rolls history it rolls at a +5.  The +7 is correct.  The same is true for pretty much all of her other skills, too; they're either rolling too low or too high, but they're always correct on her sheet.  The character's name is "Willa Sweetgrass" and this is in my "The Victorious Secret" game.

What you're experiencing may be caused by an issue that can occur when switching over to the 5e OGL sheet from another Character Sheet (see the note in Adding the Character Sheet to a Campaign ). On the Attributes & Abilities Tab of the affected Characters, try locating and deleting all Attributes which have a name similar to: "PB" or "pb" " <skill> _bonus"; e.g. "deception_bonus" " <ability> _save_bonus"; e.g. "wisdom_save_bonus" " <ability> _mod"; e.g. "strength_mod" To delete an Attribute, hover over it and press the x button that appears.

I have similar ongoing problems where the roll includes the proficiency bonus but not the stat bonus. is the fix you stated likely to deal with this?

I wrote a quick bit of code to dig into this, as suggested by @Silvyre.  Code is here: function processCommand(evt) { const [command, ...args] = evt.content.split(' '); debug(`${evt.who} sent ${command}${args ? ' ' + args.join(' ') : null}.`); switch (command) { case '!shapechanger': shapechange(evt); break; case '!resize': resize(evt, args); break; case '!follow': follow(evt, ...args); break; case '!debug': debugTokenProperties(evt, ...args); break; case '!searchForTokenAnomalies': searchForTokenAnomalies(evt, ...args); break; case '!cleanupTokenAnomalies': cleanupTokenAnomalies(evt, ...args); break; } } function debugTokenProperties (evt, selectedId) { const tokens = getSelectedTokens(evt); tokens.forEach((token) => { const represents = token.get('represents'); const name = token.get('name'); debug(`Token For ${name} (${represents})`); const attributes = getAllSheetAttributes(represents); attributes.forEach((attribute) => { const attrName = attribute.get('name'); debug(` - ${attrName}`); }) }); } function searchForTokenAnomalies (evt, selectedId) { const tokens = getSelectedTokens(evt); tokens.forEach((token) => { const represents = token.get('represents'); const name = token.get('name'); debug(`Token For ${name} (${represents})`); const attributes = getAllSheetAttributes(represents); attributes .map((attribute) => attribute.get('name')) .filter(filterAnomalousAttributes) .forEach((attribute) => { const attrObj = getSheetAttribute(represents, attribute); const value = attrObj.get('current'); debug(` - ${attribute}: ${value}`); }); }); } function cleanupTokenAnomalies (evt, selectedId) { const tokens = getSelectedTokens(evt); tokens.forEach((token) => { const represents = token.get('represents'); const name = token.get('name'); debug(`Token For ${name} (${represents})`); const attributes = getAllSheetAttributes(represents); attributes .map((attribute) => attribute.get('name')) .filter(filterAnomalousAttributes) .forEach((attribute) => { const attrObj = getSheetAttribute(represents, attribute); attrObj.remove(); debug(` - removed: ${attribute}`); }); }); } function filterAnomalousAttributes (attribute) { return (/pb$/i.test(attribute) || /(.*?)_(bonus$|save_bonus$|mod$|mod_with_sign$|mod_formula$)/i.test(attribute)); } Plus some utility functions for getting tokens and their attributes.  This resulted in the following output: "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.500Z] DM (GM) sent !searchForTokenAnomalies ." "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.501Z] Token For Willa (-KUATNG1WvzEaNVKYmYE)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.514Z] - pb: 2" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.520Z] - h_PB: 1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.525Z] - strength_saving_throw_mod: -1[str] + 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.532Z] - strength_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: -1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.537Z] - dexterity_saving_throw_mod: 3[dex] + 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.545Z] - dexterity_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.549Z] - constitution_saving_throw_mod: 0[con] + 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.555Z] - constitution_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.560Z] - intelligence_saving_throw_mod: 1[int] + 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.566Z] - intelligence_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.572Z] - wisdom_saving_throw_mod: 1[wis] + 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.578Z] - wisdom_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.585Z] - charisma_saving_throw_mod: 3[cha] + 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.592Z] - charisma_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.597Z] - fortitude_saving_throw_mod: 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.605Z] - fortitude_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.611Z] - reflex_saving_throw_mod: 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.616Z] - reflex_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.621Z] - will_saving_throw_mod: 0[global saving throw bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.627Z] - will_saving_throw_mod_with_sign: +0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.631Z] - strength_mod: -1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.637Z] - strength_mod_with_sign: -1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.642Z] - strength_check_mod: -1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.647Z] - strength_check_mod_with_sign: -1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.652Z] - strength_check_mod_formula: -1[str mod with bonus] + (@{global_check_bonus})[global check bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.658Z] - finesse_mod: 3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.662Z] - dexterity_mod: 3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.667Z] - dexterity_mod_with_sign: +3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.672Z] - dexterity_check_mod: 3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.676Z] - dexterity_check_mod_with_sign: +3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.681Z] - dexterity_check_mod_formula: 3[dex mod with bonus] + (@{global_check_bonus})[global check bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.689Z] - constitution_mod: 0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.695Z] - constitution_mod_with_sign: +0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.700Z] - constitution_check_mod: 0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.704Z] - constitution_check_mod_with_sign: +0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.709Z] - constitution_check_mod_formula: (@{global_check_bonus})[global check bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.714Z] - intelligence_mod: 1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.720Z] - intelligence_mod_with_sign: +1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.725Z] - intelligence_check_mod: 1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.730Z] - intelligence_check_mod_with_sign: +1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.734Z] - intelligence_check_mod_formula: 1[int mod with bonus] + (@{global_check_bonus})[global check bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.739Z] - wisdom_mod: 1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.744Z] - wisdom_mod_with_sign: +1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.749Z] - wisdom_check_mod: 1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.754Z] - wisdom_check_mod_with_sign: +1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.760Z] - wisdom_check_mod_formula: 1[wis mod with bonus] + (@{global_check_bonus})[global check bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.764Z] - charisma_mod: 3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.769Z] - charisma_mod_with_sign: +3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.775Z] - charisma_check_mod: 3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.780Z] - charisma_check_mod_with_sign: +3" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.785Z] - charisma_check_mod_formula: 3[cha mod with bonus] + (@{global_check_bonus})[global check bonus]" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.793Z] - charisma_bonus: 1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.801Z] - wisdom_bonus: 0" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.812Z] - charisma_save_bonus: " "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.819Z] - dexterity_save_bonus: " "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.826Z] - constitution_save_bonus: " "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.832Z] - wisdom_save_bonus: " "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.840Z] - intelligence_save_bonus: " "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.845Z] - strength_save_bonus: " "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.853Z] - dexterity_bonus: 2" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.863Z] - d20_mod: ro<1" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.882Z] - npcd_str_mod: (-1)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.888Z] - npcd_dex_mod: (+0)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.894Z] - npcd_con_mod: (+1)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.899Z] - npcd_int_mod: (+1)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.904Z] - npcd_wis_mod: (+3)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:09.908Z] - npcd_cha_mod: (+3)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.917Z] DM (GM) sent !cleanupTokenAnomalies ." "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.918Z] Token For Willa (-KUATNG1WvzEaNVKYmYE)" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.938Z] - removed: pb" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.948Z] - removed: h_PB" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.958Z] - removed: strength_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.968Z] - removed: strength_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.979Z] - removed: dexterity_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.988Z] - removed: dexterity_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:20.998Z] - removed: constitution_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.008Z] - removed: constitution_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.018Z] - removed: intelligence_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.028Z] - removed: intelligence_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.038Z] - removed: wisdom_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.046Z] - removed: wisdom_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.055Z] - removed: charisma_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.064Z] - removed: charisma_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.073Z] - removed: fortitude_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.081Z] - removed: fortitude_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.092Z] - removed: reflex_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.102Z] - removed: reflex_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.113Z] - removed: will_saving_throw_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.123Z] - removed: will_saving_throw_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.131Z] - removed: strength_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.139Z] - removed: strength_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.151Z] - removed: strength_check_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.161Z] - removed: strength_check_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.173Z] - removed: strength_check_mod_formula" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.182Z] - removed: finesse_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.192Z] - removed: dexterity_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.201Z] - removed: dexterity_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.212Z] - removed: dexterity_check_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.221Z] - removed: dexterity_check_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.234Z] - removed: dexterity_check_mod_formula" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.244Z] - removed: constitution_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.252Z] - removed: constitution_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.267Z] - removed: constitution_check_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.279Z] - removed: constitution_check_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.288Z] - removed: constitution_check_mod_formula" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.297Z] - removed: intelligence_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.307Z] - removed: intelligence_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.315Z] - removed: intelligence_check_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.323Z] - removed: intelligence_check_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.331Z] - removed: intelligence_check_mod_formula" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.341Z] - removed: wisdom_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.354Z] - removed: wisdom_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.362Z] - removed: wisdom_check_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.370Z] - removed: wisdom_check_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.378Z] - removed: wisdom_check_mod_formula" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.386Z] - removed: charisma_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.394Z] - removed: charisma_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.403Z] - removed: charisma_check_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.411Z] - removed: charisma_check_mod_with_sign" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.420Z] - removed: charisma_check_mod_formula" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.428Z] - removed: charisma_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.436Z] - removed: wisdom_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.445Z] - removed: charisma_save_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.454Z] - removed: dexterity_save_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.463Z] - removed: constitution_save_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.471Z] - removed: wisdom_save_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.479Z] - removed: intelligence_save_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.489Z] - removed: strength_save_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.497Z] - removed: dexterity_bonus" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.514Z] - removed: d20_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.525Z] - removed: npcd_str_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.537Z] - removed: npcd_dex_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.547Z] - removed: npcd_con_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.554Z] - removed: npcd_int_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.567Z] - removed: npcd_wis_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:42:21.578Z] - removed: npcd_cha_mod" "[2017-09-04T18:44:19.592Z] DM (GM) sent !searchForTokenAnomalies ." "[2017-09-04T18:44:19.593Z] Token For Willa (-KUATNG1WvzEaNVKYmYE)" And now, after reattempting to roll History ... nothing has changed.  It's still rolling at +5 despite showing +7 on the sheet.

What does the Text Chat return when you enter @{Willa Sweetgrass|history_bonus} ?

Thomas H. said: I have similar ongoing problems where the roll includes the proficiency bonus but not the stat bonus. is the fix you stated likely to deal with this? Yes.

Silvyre said: What does the Text Chat return when you enter @{Willa Sweetgrass|history_bonus} ? ((floor((12-10)/2))+(((((ceil((5)/1e10) + ceil((5)/4)) 2) + (floor((ceil((5)/1e10) + ceil((5)/4))/2))) + abs(((ceil((5)/1e10) + ceil((5)/4)) 2) - (floor((ceil((5)/1e10) + ceil((5)/4))/2)))) / 2)+0)

Ok, so the character sheet sees the Intelligence of the character as 12 (+1 modifier) and level as 5 (+3 proficiency), this would result in +4 as the history bonus, but I believe that you have set the history to expertise to get +7. So from what it seems, the character sheet has the correct information but the connection to the history roll is off. Most likely because you just recently leveled the character to the new proficiency threshold.  My suggestion is that you try to remove the proficiency from the history skill and see if the history roll updates (should have a +1 to the roll without proficicency). If that works, set the proficiency again and see if that fixes the skill.

@Kyle G. That fixed it.  We'd done that before, but it didn't fix it previously. So I suspect it's a combination of the transition from the other sheet type (the stuff I cleaned up with my script) and the proficiencies not updating properly. :) I'll go through and uncheck/recheck everything. Thanks!