Hey Sarah! The colors aren't the issue, my friends and I actually use separate colors per person. This issue is actually different. You can test this by doing the following: Make sure there are at least 2 people in the game Set your color to Red Have them set their color to Blue (any colors will work, this will make it more noticeable though) Have your friend roll a few dice While their dice are rolling, do your own roll Their dice that are still rolling will switch to your own dice color It seems like the dice color is set to ALL existing dice as soon as the roll starts instead of being (and staying!) set to the dice particular to the user. If you need more to debug this more and/or try and get a video, let me know.