So, I just tried to Transmogrify from Fairhaven to Pencliff and got the following: There is already an existing Handouts with that ID named Pencliff Map Key & Notes. If you transfer this object, it will overwrite the existing object. Are you sure? (OK to continue, Cancel to cancel) There is already an existing Handouts with that ID named Description & History. If you transfer this object, it will overwrite the existing object. Are you sure? (OK to continue, Cancel to cancel) There is already an existing Handouts with that ID named d8 Plot Hooks / Rumors. If you transfer this object, it will overwrite the existing object. Are you sure? (OK to continue, Cancel to cancel) There is already an existing Handouts with that ID named Intro (Read First!). If you transfer this object, it will overwrite the existing object. Are you sure? (OK to continue, Cancel to cancel) (NOTE - I CANCELLED ALL OF THE ABOVE, I DID NOT OVERWRITE) I then added Fairhaven in by the usual Add-in method, and I got: Pencliff map (with numbers) overwritten by Fairhaven and everything in the Pencliff notes section overwritten by Fairhaven items (I clicked on each to confirm) Fairhaven section only has NPCs in it, everything else gets written over Pencliff (even the Fairhaven Map Key and Notes gets put in the Pencliff section, because it seems to be called Pencliff Map Key and Notes. I worked out a way around it for the game the other night, I just made copies of the Pencliff stuff first then added Fairhaven in, but I did think I was going mad at one point lol