In Pathfinder 2e, you could roll several different skills for initiative - for simplicity, i just made separate token initiative macros for Perception and Stealth, but a third possible roll type would be "Recall Knowledge" - which keys off of the relevant knowledge skill for the encounter. My thinking was that it should look like this: &{template:rolls} {{limit_height=@{Selected|roll_limit_height}}} {{charactername=@{Selected|character_name}}} {{header=^{initiative}}} {{subheader=Investigate ?{Recall Knowledge:|Arcana|Crafting|Nature|Occultism|Religion|Society}}} {{roll01=[[1d20cs20cf1 + (@{Selected| ?{Recall Knowledge:|Arcana|Crafting|Nature|Occultism|Religion|Society}})[Recall Knowledge ?{Recall Knowledge:|Arcana|Crafting|Nature|Occultism|Religion|Society}] &{tracker}]]}} The Recall Knowledge Pulldown prompt should allow the player to select the appropriate skill, and then the roll take place (with the skill name also showing up in the template sub-header and as a description of the modifier if you hover over the roll in chat.. As is - it gives an error message, but calls for the skill selection. and upon selecting a skill - it does actually roll the dice, but it seems like it is rolling without the benefit of the selected skill's modifier I had tried using that google sheet that substitutes out problematic characters with the html replacement codes (e.g., & = &amp, }} = &#125, etc) The result of using that process is: &{template:rolls} {{limit_height=@{Selected|roll_limit_height}}} {{charactername=@{Selected|character_name}}} {{header=^{initiative}}} {{subheader=Investigate ?{Recall Knowledge:|Arcana|Crafting|Nature|Occultism|Religion|Society}}} {{roll01=[[1d20cs20cf1 + (@{Selected| ?{Recall Knowledge:|Arcana|Crafting|Nature|Occultism|Religion|Society}})[Recall Knowledge ?{Recall Knowledge:|Arcana|Crafting|Nature|Occultism|Religion|Society}] &{tracker}]]}} But this looks all kinds of messed up when i run the macro Can anyone give mew some advice or help fixing this?