If you're willing to use custom macros, the npcdmg template neatly stacks with itself: &{template:npcdmg}{{damage=1}}{{dmg1flag=1}}{{dmg1=[[2d6]]}}{{dmg1type=Piercing}} &{template:npcdmg}{{damage=1}}{{dmg1flag=1}}{{dmg1=[[2d4]]}}{{dmg1type=Fire}} &{template:npcdmg}{{damage=1}}{{dmg1flag=1}}{{dmg1=[[1d6]]}}{{dmg1type=Lightning}} &{template:npcdmg}{{damage=1}}{{dmg1flag=1}}{{dmg1=[[1d4]]}}{{dmg1type=Force}} Keith's version is much easier and can be done straight through the sheet - bear in mind it won't automatically roll crit if it's not in the 2 pre-made damage sections. Another options is to stack two of them into one damage field, [[2d6]][Bludgeoning]+[[2d4]][Fire] , and mouse-over to see the breakdown.