Thanks William, You need to include a 2nd attack ie {{attack2}}. Otherwise the roll template doesn't have any way to confirm a crit for the 2nd attack, and therefore will not show crit damage for the 2nd attack. example; &{template:pf_attack} {{name=@{repeating_weapon_$1_name}}} {{attack=[[ 1d20cs>19 + [[ @{repeating_weapon_$1_total-attack} ]] ]] vs AC }} {{attack2=[[ 1d20cs>19 + [[ @{repeating_weapon_$1_total-attack} ]] ]] vs AC }} {{damage=[[ 1d6 +[[ @{repeating_weapon_$1_total-damage} ]] ]]}} {{damage2=[[ 1d6 +[[ @{repeating_weapon_$1_total-damage} ]] ]]}} {{crit_confirm=[[ 1d20 + [[@{repeating_weapon_$1_total-attack}]] ]] }} {{crit_damage=[[ 2d6 + ( [[ @{repeating_weapon_$1_total-damage} ]]*2) ]]}} {{crit_confirm2=[[ 1d20 + [[@{repeating_weapon_$1_total-attack}]] ]] }} {{crit_damage2=[[ 2d6 + ( [[ @{repeating_weapon_$1_total-damage} ]]*2) ]]}} After looking at the Battlemind Link spell; shouldn't the caster and an ally both roll an attack and both get to take the higher roll of either the caster or ally? The macro above seems more like "advantage" from 5e.