First sanity check: are you sure you are checking the correct game? (Sometimes GMs will copy a game, and a player is active in the original but not the copy, etc.) If so, do you see them on the Game Page in the invited players section? If not, then they either accidentally left the game, or got booted somehow and need to be reinvited. Make sure to send them a new game link. If so, do you see them on the 'Edit and Control' dropdown for a character? If they are listed as an active/invited player, but are not showing up in the 'Edit and Control' dropdown, then try booting them from the game and reinviting them, as that's possibly just a bug. If that still doesn't work, then something else is going on. Try loading the game in an incognito browser just to make sure there's not an extension interfering. If that still doesn't work then you'll likely have to submit a Help Center request .