Okay, thanks a ton! I think I have something pretty close to what I want, but I have some macro specific questions now. I'm sure I'm doing something that simply doesn't work, but I'm not quite sure why. As far as I can figure, {value1, value2}kh1 does not work inside an input modifier choice (not sure what the technical term for it is). Here is my macro. I spaced it out for readability. In short, this macro does not do anything when I submit my choice. ?{Advantage? | Normal, [[ 1t[D6] ]] | Keen, [[ { 1t[D6], 1t[D6] }kh1 ]] | Snakebit, [[ { 1t[D6], 1t[D6] }kl1 ]] } However, this macro does work, but I'm not sure how I can fix this. ?{Advantage? | Normal, [[ 1t[D6] ]] | Keen, [[ 1t[D6] ]] | Snakebit, [[ 1t[D6] ]] } Ideally I would be able to do [[ 2t[D6]kh ]], but it is pretty clear in the docs that 2t[TABLE] does not work inline. I know I'm ignoring modifiers right now. I figure once I get this working I can make the inline be [[ 1t[D6]+?{Modifier} ]] for that. Any idea how to get an advantage/ disadvantage choice working for this? If it can't be done then so be it, but it'd be nice.