Thanks timmaugh, that did the trick on that part. I tried several other things, and found a solution with the Default Template that actually works! The code is a bit of a behemoth, but it seems to work without issue. The output looks like this: (I renamed the spell to Raw instead of Jim's) Here's the ability macro for it, which is on a character's sheet: ?{Cast at what level?|Level 1,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}|Level 2,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}|Level 3,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}|Level 4,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}|Level 5,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}|Level 6,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}|Level 7,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}|Level 8,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}&rbrace|Level 9,&{template:default} {{name=Raw Magic Missiles%NEWLINE% Attacks and Damage ([Crits](`/r 5d4))}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}} {{[[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]] | [[1d20+@{spell_attack_bonus}]]= [[2d4]] Force}}} I decided to make a simple button in the header for the Crits, though the calculation could be a bit prettier. For some reason the [Crits](`[[5d4]] force) did not seem to work well. I made use of 2 attack rolls, as I was too lazy to figure out how to get the code to check the character sheet's toggle for advantage/disadvantage/normal/always. This should also work for other multiple ray spells like Scorching Ray and even Eldritch Blast, with some adjustments.