I am not a new user, so I don't really know what is better for them, but having a centralized post doesn't seems like a bad thing to have for them. It's seems easier (at least for me) to find the info you are looking for. From the point of view of a sheet author (that I'm not) I think a centralized post is easier for you to keep track on what's happening, especially after an update (bugs,...). I mean, you asked to centralize all the bugs for the 5e OGL sheet, and that seems like a reasonable thing to do. And while you can fix all the bugs in 1 week, all sheet authors cannot work that fast. Imagine that, in 4 days, you don't have fixed all the bugs in your sheet. That would not be really practical to see your post disappear from the front page. If your goal is simply to not have huge thread, why not simply ask sheet authors to do a new post when it gets too huge ? As a regular user who go sometimes on the forums, it's certainly easier to follow to the post devoted to your sheet so you can see what's happening, rather than going every 3-4 days on the forums to see if there is something new. "Follow topic" is maybe not there for us to see the updates, but it's the only way for us to see them, unless you go on the forums every day. If you find a alternative way, then I don't see any problem for me as a regular user. So, while this is maybe better for the new users, I think it is worse for sheet authors and regular users. I can understand that you want to promote new things (well, for API at least, I'm totally ok with that), but I think that old big topics with new things really need a place in the front page as well. Naturally, if that really slow you down from a technical point of view, well, I can understand that you don't want to see Kryx having 1k posts :p . Finally, I'm gonna be a bit more annoying and says that this would be a great feature, not for the sheet sub-forum, but for the Suggestion & Ideas sub-forum. The suggestions on the front page haven't change for a long time (since it's vote based), and two of them even have the "complete" tag. I don't really see the utility of them being on the front page (other than reminding you every day what the community want the most, but I think you already know that :p).