Can not see or reread new posts to a thread

I started up a game and made it public to get players. In the post section I put a Application post with guidelines on how to join. While I do get responses to the post and get on the notifications to see it, I can not go back at a later time to reread the posts if no new ones were sent to it. The post even says there is no reply's to it yet. 

Hi Adam J. By  default  a game  is  only  visible to players  already   in the game, and only  Plus and Pro  subscribers  can   make their games  visible to the public , but even then people not in the game can not post to the forums. The best way to handle this situation is to  create a Looking for Group listing ; even if you do not enable it for viewing in the LFG Directory you can share the  link  with others and have a separate  Listing Discussion forum  just for those potentially interested in your game. As a bonus, anyone who posts to your game's Listing Discussion forum will have a  big blue button  by their username and all a GM has to is click 'Invite to Game' and an invitation will be sent their way. I hope this helps, happy gaming! :)

I am sorry I choose wrong words so it is more confusing than it should be. I do have the game listed as Looking for Group ( not public). Yeah I can only see when they post a reply when I go to the post via notification. If I try to go the the post itself I will only see what I post and nothing else. Even when someone puts a new post down in the game forum.