This sounds like some steps are being performed out of order. Setting the default token must be the last step. Any alterations done after that step are not saved. Think of setting the default tokens as akin to saving your work in a word processor doc. If you save the doc and then add a paragraph without saving again, that paragraph will not be there next time you open the doc. Also, since you are Pro, make sure you do not have a script that is interfering with your settings. For example, Health Aura can result in the behavior you are describing (it can be turned off in the config settings)