Ah, Then this is likely an issue involving default tokens. The default token tied to a character is tied to that specific character. Lets call it "Abel". If you duplicate Abel, and name it "Baker", the default token does not change; it's really a separate entity, and is still tied to Abel. When you duplicate Abel and rename it to Baker, pull out the default token onto the tabletop and reassign it to Baker. Then edit Baker, delete its default token and use the selected Baker Token to be the default token for the Baker sheet. I had thought that ToA included Compendium-level creatures. My mistake.