I have had this happen to me, and happened to a player. Of course we just made up the best answer we could remember to restore the points. Would have used "Undo" at that moment if it was available. Following this thread to see what The Aaron and the community comes up with. For me I agree with Three's idea of adding it to your Token-Mod, mainly since I already use Token-Mod, but also because this feature sounds related and would only ever be used/needed on a token (that has bars). History could be neat as an added feature -- for majority of times when the number is correctly added/subtracted. What if it could later output the token's "Hit Point history"? Example: "Astro Aaron has been down to 1 HP, 28 times in his adventuring career so far". Or, "Gold's Dragon has been hit.... 76 times" (and they still haven't killed it). If you were tracking/storing the changes in the value anyway.