I have had this issue on every vtt I have played in so far. I didn't find anything quite like this when searching the forums, so here goes: Step 1) I create a character sheet and associate both an avatar and a default token (different images) Step 2) I drag the character from the handouts section onto the board. It works as normal. Step 3) I export character from vault to a different game. Step 4) The GM drags my character to the play area and the token is created using the avatar on that sheet, not the default token. Step 5) I drag the character onto the play area and the default token is created as expected. This has happened with every character and in every game I have played so far.