So i have DM'd since lock-down (took a year out but am back to it) - and i started a campaign earlier... One of my players brought up something which i always thought i KNEW... (I was taught a specific way as a DM from other DMs who play roll20) The argument is as follows: Player: am i rolling with advantage? Me: No Player: Rolls with *Always roll Advantage* Player: Rolls 23 (nat + bonus) on left side... rolls 7 on right side Me: Ok, you fail Player: WTF!!! ITS A NAT 20!!! Me: This is without advantage... Player: Yes then you ALWAYS take the number on the left!!! Me: No... if its a straight roll you take the LOWEST number Player: NO YOU ALWAYS TAKE THE NUMBER ON THE LEFT!!! OR IT IS DISADVANTAGE!!! Me: Fine, lets just get through this session and i will check later ----------------------------------------------------------------------- I personally was taught if it is *always roll advantage* and its a normal roll you take the lower number - who is correct? And if i am wrong, why have 4 other DMs ruled it the way i have? Cheers