Can't stop auto rolling damage

I'm relatively new here so I may be missing something obvious. I am running a 5e game as GM and have set the settings as don't auto roll damage but when I click on a monsters attack it auto rolls the hit and damage (&crit) at the same time. I've been back to settings and it is set on "don't auto roll damage".  How is can I get it to not auto roll the damage? also sometimes it asks me if I want to roll the to hit publicly and sometimes it just rolls it publicly (it always auto rolls damage though) is there some way to deal with this as well that I'm not seeing?

If you'd created the character before you had made the changes in the settings, it won't work for this character until you change it on the sheet too, as here on the 5OGL Sheet:

I believe that you are experiencing this situation because you are making the changes in the games default settings. However, these changes only take place on NEW characters created after the settings have changed. The changes do not affect characters already created. In order to get the correct settings on pre-existing characters, there is a button in the in-game settings