notBowen said: DM Mark said: Bryan K. said: Honestly, I'm just going to let it slide on the multiple rerolls and I imagine other DMs would too. For years? We want people going around saying "Sure, you could use Roll20 to play D&D, but it doesn't really support all the standard things you can do in the PHB, like a normal re-roll"? Seems like one of those "cheap to fix, expensive not to" type situations, from a public relations perspective. Also, seems like a more major issue to me than that. In my 2d6 example, 1/3 of all the re-rolls would be inaccurate (1/3 of all re-rolls of a d6 are a 1 or 2). For example, I just did /roll 2d6r<2 and got three re-rolls on the first die and one re-roll on the second die, until it finally had no 1s or 2s counting. It's something that is likely to come up almost every combat, and people are just going to hand-waive the difference between a creature dropping or not, for years, just because? To echo what the other poster said Roll20 has always been about preserving the tabletop experience. Automation has crept in based on user demand but Roll20 will never be comprehensive. If you were at a table and rolled a die that then required a reroll, the die wouldn't magically reroll itself. If you've issues with the amount of rerolls required for this particular mechanic you should take it up with WotC. Roll20 already supports a certain re-roll mechanic with a special built-in command. However, it only supports it for the 4e mechanic, not the 5e mechanic. All I am asking is that it support it for the 5e mechanic. That's not WOTC's fault - they just put out an edition that Roll20 wants to support. But Roll20 already committed to the idea it would support re-rolls with an automatic (or "magically reroll" if you prefer) command, and I am just saying then there should be one for the current edition of D&D too. I don't think that is asking for a lot. I also don't think it's asking for it to be comprehensive when I am asking for it to support a very common thing, in a very common game, concerning a topic Roll20 has already supported for a different version of that same game.