D&D 5E (2024) Character Sheet & Builder by Roll20

ErrantX said: There are several issues with the character sheet wizard with the new Forge of the Artificer content not loading into it - specifically related to Artificer Plans and Skill Proficiencies. Just a heads up! -X Thanks for reporting - can you give any specific examples? Is it the same issue each time? Or random? Does it work intermittently or not at all? Thanks!

Michael P. said: I have been playing around with the shop builder in the 2024 character sheet and I have some feedback. I hope this helps because I have found the Shops feature so handy. I usually make general gear shops for the purposes of player shopping trips. Armorer, Weaponsmith, Alchemist/Herbalist, and a General Store for adventuring gear. Lately I have been trying out creating taverns, inns, stables, and other "services" type establishments. One thing I have encountered across the board is a desire for delineate groupings within a shop. For example, a blacksmith that sells tools, weapons and armor would need separate sections for each group and possibly sub categories like simple and martial weapons, light, medium, and heavy armor, and shields. Another would be for a Woodworker/Carpenter to have sections for weapons (quarterstaffs, bows, clubs) and gear (like chests, barrels, and wands). This is especially important with the other types of shops I've been working on that essentially have menus. I could just copy and paste the information for services out of the players handbook (ale 4cp, bread 2cp, modest meal 1sp, wealthy meal 3sp etc) but that kinda takes the life out of what make the shop feature so great. I want to include a selection of drinks and food for the players to choose from. It's easy enough to do, but it looks messy and disorganized. Hi Michael P!! I'm David, the dev responsible for Loot Manager (Shops & Treasure)! While I haven't had the bandwidth lately to be able to make any new changes to these sheet types, I am eager to get back to them and implement some of the awesome feedback we've gotten. I love this idea and am definitely adding it to my to-do list. I also use Shops to offer services, and having those delineated would be excellent!

Shane said: Apologies if this has been covered before, but I am finally coming around to the official 2024 sheet as I believe it has come a long way, with one caveat. There doesn't appear to be a way to change the order of actions as there was in the old 5E sheet. For instance, monsters with multiattack - multiattack appears at the bottom of possible actions. I want this to appear at the top as it did with the old sheet. One could drag and rearrange the possible actions on the old sheet. is this not possible with the new sheet at the moment? If not, is it a known request or issue? Small issue... Custom ordering only exists on the PC side right now, but NPCs are sorted alphabetically so you can work around it by renaming them to sort where you need them to be until it exists on both sides. We're working towards having it for NPCs, but there are a few upgrades we want to do behind-the-scenes before going through UI changes on those rows. Thought  said: -Sharpshooter snip- Got it, I'll make a ticket for this. It looks like a poor interaction between us trying to show you what your damage roll will be, and then adding roll bonuses - the first row should be 1d12+5, not +15, but it's using the same display we use to show you the total instead. Master Azroth said: Big overlook on the Custom Class section of the Builder. 1: There is no "Existing Resource" Modifier, there needs to be one so different abilities can link back to the same resource. 2: There is no way to have resources increase at higher levels, again I think having an  "Existing Resource" Modifier and bumping up the max would most likely fix this as long as different max overrides the lower level on and does not break the resource. 3: There is no way to link a resource max link to your proficiency bonus. These would allow the custom class to function sheet-wise the way the other classes do. Still a Custom problem but not necessarily a builder problem is the ability to build sub-abilities into a toggle. For example Monk when made in the Builder has an "Effect" toggle that when toggled adds a new attack, a new toggle and new " action economy" Right now we can't do this manually but it would be so very helpful if we could, and again  allow the custom class to function  sheet-wise the way the other classes do. *Edit: Forgot to add that this also needs to work for custom subclasses as well. Thanks for the feedback! This is how it is right now because of the specific ways builder and sheet interact so it's going to be a tougher lift than it looks. You can add those existing resource on the sheet once it's built, though. Der Arkanier said: Hi all, We just tested the Expansion Eberon 2024 and found a bug in the builder. I created an artificer and the builder does not work as intended. On LV 1 I can select 2 LV 1 spells as intended. On LV3 the artficier is supposed to get another LV1 spell but the builder does not show any options, nor does it on LV5. On LV5 can select only 2 LV2 Spells . But going up till LV7 I cannot select another LV2 Spell. So, by LV 7 I am supposed to have 4 LV1 spells and 3 LV2 spells prepared but according the builder I have only 2 LV1 spells and 2 LV2 spells. Could you pass that on to the right team to get that fixed? And some more detail on an already reported bug. Or actually another bug but they might be in correlation: I already mentioned that query mode for Ability Checks and saving throws just do not work. the query windows does not open and I just get a straight roll although I have situational advantage on wisdom saves. So far so bad. Now here is another bug: If I set up an effect on the sheet that grants advantage on intimidation but disadvantage on all other charisma checks, that effect works correctly for all skill checks; The query windows opens up and I there can change or confirm the advantage setting for that specific role. If I pick advantage or disadvantage for only that roll, the setting sticks. So, If I afterwards do an ability check or saving throw, the roll is made with either advantage or disadvantage - depending on what was chosen for the previous skill check. Without opening the query window first, so that I could not adjust any settings. In my example this goes not only for Charisma checks or Saves but for all other saves, too. So, I actually should have disadvantage on charisma checks according to the modifier. But since I made an intimidation roll with advantage,  now all subsequent ability saves are made with advantage. This behaviour does not change, as well, when deactivating the effect toggle. The only way to get back to straight rolls is switching to automatic mode. I hope you are finding a fix for that odd behaviour. Thanks! Addressing the query window bug first - this response is delayed but that should have been resolved before the holidays. I remember talking about the weirdness between different versions of Artificer and their spell selection before the holidays but not the outcome. I'll follow up tomorrow. Noodle said: Issues that came up during yesterday's session: - With the sheet update, the Cleric feature Warding Flare no longer shows check boxes on either Combat or Features tabs, and nothing done to the feature changes that. I see this has been discussed already and we've already come up with alternatives on our end but thought I'd show that it's happening here too. - Query mode does not work for ability rolls or saves anymore, but does still work for weapon attacks and skill chekcs etc.i.e the modal never opens, and assumes that all queryable toggles are turned on.  - 4 digit numbers in the currency boxes (gold etc.) can't be read as the 4th number is behind the UI - Clicking damage from the Spells tab doesn't add any Effects that affect damage. Otherwise absolutely loving the new sheet editing capabilities - especially the way that Conditions work. Being able to simply type the name of a druid beast form instead of opening up a huge modal which needs lots of scrolling is a massive QOL change for my druid player (the beast forms are custom).  We're working on the resource thing, promise! Query mode is fixed 4 digit feedback is noted, thank you! We wanted to make these always editable but we only have so much space. We may have to rethink a bit how to make that work. There's definitely something weird going on here. I'll dig into it more tomorrow. Glad you like inline editing though!! --- I'll come back to the rest of these, but it's a start on catching up now that everyone is back :)

Tara said: Feature Request: Allow spells like Hellish Rebuke and Silvery Barbs to appear in the "Reactions" section of the Combat tab Thanks for the feedback! On the whole, the organization of the Combat tab could use a once-over to ensure it makes the most sense. Brian C. said: A few things that are causing me issues: In a game with 2014 NPC sheets and 2024 PC sheets, accidentally switching from 2014 to the 2024 sheet overwrites all my 2014 sheets with empty 2024 sheets, and I can no longer switch those sheets back to 2014 sheets. I have to roll back the game. Attacks should have access to the Existing Resource modifier so that someone can reduce the number of uses of a special attack. Barbarian primal rage is not correctly implemented from several angles. First, the change to using Strength as the ability for Acrobatics, Intimidation, Perception, Stealth, and Survival should only happen while rage is applied instead of from within the Primal Rage feature, where it is always applied. Second, the rage effect should be giving advantage to those skills as they are now (for most barbarians) Strength ability checks. To properly fix this, we need a Skill Ability override modifier added to the rage effect which switches these skills to use Strength while Rage is active. For the few barbarians who have Strength lower than Dexterity or Wisdom, they could delete unnecessary modifiers from the Rage effect as necessary. I have a piecemeal solution in the Rage effect, but it requires me to modify it whenever a relevant Ability score changes. 1. We are looking at ways to prevent the data from wiping if you open a 2014 character in a 2024 sheet, but it requires a lot of background work to get there. 2. Thanks for the feedback! We're working on bringing custom resource management to actions first. 3. I assume you mean Primal Knowledge based on the rest of this question? While it may look like from the modifier builder that the skills are always being modified, that's not really how it works - you can test it and see that when you turn rage on, the totals for those skills change. This is part of the data that's a little behind-the-scenes, because it's written in a way where it can live underneath the feature, but be added to the Rage effect. The advantage part isn't handled though, you're right. Feedback noted.  Sage said: How do we give an extra attack to the class You can just add it as a feature. There is no automation for "extra attack per turn" on the sheet, it's just text you enter as a feature so you know during combat. Erudo  said: I'm using the built-in 'Add Action to Token Bar' for a cantrip (Sacred Flame). It activates the cantrip but the DC is wrong. It seems to be missing the ability bonus. If activating from the Combat or Spell in the sheet itself, the DC is correct. This is for a single-classed Cleric, although note that the character was created way back when the 2024 sheet was a few months old.  I have another character - Wizard - which is working fine. Has anyone else ran across this issue? We're working on this! Andrea L. said: I tried experimenting with shop too and maybe I'm missing pieces. I'd like to create a weapon shop of a lot of very mundane items Drag and drop work puts 1 in and then you can change the number but how do you delete it if it is wrong? If I use instead the builder I cannot select more than 10 items and after they are generated I cannot remove some (no musket in my world...) am I missing something? Andrea Just to the left of the quantity input there is a remove button, it looks like a red circle with a minus in it. When you click it, it will ask you to confirm that you want to remove that item, and then remove it from the sheet. This is also possible when generating items, you can just remove the ones you don't like before clicking "Add to Inventory". Erudo said: Certain spells like Searing Smite will output only the damage box when clicked. If I wanted to show the spell details (for others to review), I need to separately use the speech balloon icon. Similar spells like Staggering Smite don't have this problem, where it will output both the spell detail box and the spell damage box. I would like a way to change Searing Smite to be more like Staggering Smite. I figured out that this is something to do with the 'Damage Only' checkbox, which unfortunately I can't untick because doing so breaks the default damage formula in Searing Smite, and I can't recreate it because the upcast formula is not exposed and is not editable. Does anyone have a workaround? In summary, I'd like to be able to 'force' spells like Searing Smite to be able to output both the spell details and the spell damage boxes. There is a hacky way to do this. Searing Smite is considered what we consider an "automatically hitting" attack. First, in the combat tab, you need to go into the advanced editing and remove that. Then, exit the advanced editing and change the type of the attack from Spell Attack to Spell Save. That will give you the spell save output that Staggering Smite has, but maintain the data, damage, and upcasting of Searing Smite.