Magik said: Ok, I haven't been able to find any issues with the whisper thing in PF Beta. The default seems to work fine and, as Dizzy found, you can set both to Public and the problem goes away. It doesn't seem possible now, but one GM of mine preferred that Skill rolls for things that produce results of your character that are visible are to be Public, but the rest needed to be whispered (like knowledge checks). So, in that case what should a player do? Would they set both to Public on the Config tab and then modify their Macro Text on the hidden skills to have @{PC-whisper=/w gm} ? Yep, editing the macro-text will always over-ride the default macro. Just remove the the whisper toggle attribute if you don't want it so it doesn't interfere. The whisper attribute(As set on the Config page) either substitutes a space for public rolls or /w gm for whispers. @{PC-whisper} are used on the PC side of the sheet and @{NPC-whisper} are used on the NPC side of the sheet. Known Issue: rolling attacks from both sides of the sheet (attack attributes are shared), whichever side you roll an attack from on the sheet first is going to set the attacks macro-text to either @{PC-whisper} or @{NPC-whisper}. If you then decide you don't want that particular whisper, either reset the macro-text, reload and use the appropriate attack to set the whisper toggle or edit the macro you want to use with the whisper you want.